Black Beauty

Primary & ElementaryChallengingReading Comprehension

Read the following extract carefully, then answer the question below:

"They were going out of the stable, when John stopped and said, “I had better mention that we have never used the check-rein with either of them; the black horse never had one on, and the dealer said it was the gag-bit that spoiled the other's temper.”

“Well,” said York, “if they come here they must wear the check-rein. I prefer a loose rein myself, and his lordship is always very reasonable about horses; but my lady—that's another thing; she will have style, and if her carriage horses are not reined up tight she wouldn't look at them. I always stand out against the gag-bit, and shall do so, but it must be tight up when my lady rides!”

“I am sorry for it, very sorry,” said John; “but I must go now, or I shall lose the train.”

He came round to each of us to pat and speak to us for the last time; his voice sounded very sad.

I held my face close to him; that was all I could do to say good-by; and then he was gone, and I have never seen him since.

The next day Lord W—— came to look at us; he seemed pleased with our appearance.

“I have great confidence in these horses,” he said, “from the character my friend Mr. Gordon has given me of them. Of course they are not a match in color, but my idea is that they will do very well for the carriage while we are in the country. Before we go to London I must try to match Baron; the black horse, I believe, is perfect for riding.”

York then told him what John had said about us.

“Well,” said he, “you must keep an eye to the mare, and put the check-rein easy; I dare say they will do very well with a little humoring at first. I'll mention it to your lady.”

In the afternoon we were harnessed and put in the carriage, and as the stable clock struck three we were led round to the front of the house. It was all very grand, and three or four times as large as the old house at Birtwick, but not half so pleasant, if a horse may have an opinion. Two footmen were standing ready, dressed in drab livery, with scarlet breeches and white stockings. Presently we heard the rustling sound of silk as my lady came down the flight of stone steps. She stepped round to look at us; she was a tall, proud-looking woman, and did not seem pleased about something, but she said nothing, and got into the carriage. This was the first time of wearing a check-rein, and I must say, though it certainly was a nuisance not to be able to get my head down now and then, it did not pull my head higher than I was accustomed to carry it. I felt anxious about Ginger, but she seemed to be quiet and content.

Question: What is a 'check-rein' (also referred to as 'bearing rein' elsewhere in the novel) and why is it a point of concern or contention among the characters, including Black Beauty, in this extract? Explain the different perspectives presented.

💡 Writing Tips

  • •

    To answer this question, first look for direct mentions or descriptions of the check-rein. Then, identify all the characters who discuss it (John, York, Lord W, Black Beauty) and note down their specific opinions or feelings about it. Pay attention to descriptive words or phrases used by each character. Consider what the check-rein represents for each of them – is it about comfort, appearance, safety, or tradition?

📝 Sample Answer

A 'check-rein' (or bearing rein) is a piece of harness used on carriage horses to keep their heads held high in a particular, often unnaturally high, position. It is a point of significant concern and contention for several reasons:

  • John's Perspective: John is very worried about the check-rein. He explicitly states that they have "never used the check-rein" and recalls that a "gag-bit" (a similar restrictive device) previously "spoiled the other's temper" (referring to Ginger). His sadness when leaving, saying "I am sorry for it, very sorry," indicates his strong belief that the device will be detrimental to the horses' well-being and temperament, suggesting it's inhumane.
  • Mr. York's Perspective: York, while stating that the horses "must wear the check-rein" due to 'my lady's' wishes, admits he personally "prefer[s] a loose rein." He understands John's concerns and knows that the gag-bit is problematic, but feels he has little choice in the matter due to Lady W's demand for "style." This shows he's caught between what he believes is right for the horses and the demands of his employer.
  • Lord W's Perspective: Lord W seems more reasonable than his wife. He trusts the horses' character and instructs York to "put the check-rein easy," suggesting a willingness to compromise for the horses' comfort, at least initially. He intends to "mention it to your lady," indicating he acknowledges the issue and the potential for discomfort.
  • Black Beauty's Perspective: From the horse's own narration, wearing the check-rein for the first time is described as a "nuisance not to be able to get my head down now and then." Although initially it didn't pull his head higher than accustomed, the term "nuisance" clearly indicates it is an inconvenience and uncomfortable, hinting at worse experiences to come.

Did You Know?

You can use the atoply app to practise this prompt and get instant feedback to help improve your writing skills.

Practice This Prompt
Black Beauty | Reading Comprehension Prompt | atoply