Anne Of Green Gables
Consider Anne's long speech, which reveals a mix of feelings about Green Gables:
'Oh, I don’t mean just the tree; of course it’s lovely—yes, it’s radiantly lovely—it blooms as if it meant it—but I meant everything, the garden and the orchard and the brook and the woods, the whole big dear world. Don’t you feel as if you just loved the world on a morning like this? And I can hear the brook laughing all the way up here. Have you ever noticed what cheerful things brooks are? They’re always laughing. Even in winter-time I’ve heard them under the ice. I’m so glad there’s a brook near Green Gables. Perhaps you think it doesn’t make any difference to me when you’re not going to keep me, but it does. I shall always like to remember that there is a brook at Green Gables even if I never see it again. If there wasn’t a brook I’d be haunted by the uncomfortable feeling that there ought to be one. I’m not in the depths of despair this morning. I never can be in the morning. Isn’t it a splendid thing that there are mornings? But I feel very sad. I’ve just been imagining that it was really me you wanted after all and that I was to stay here for ever and ever. It was a great comfort while it lasted. But the worst of imagining things is that the time comes when you have to stop and that hurts.'
Task:
Anne says, "I’m not in the depths of despair this morning. I never can be in the morning. Isn’t it a splendid thing that there are mornings? But I feel very sad."
Explain the apparent contradiction in her feelings and what causes her underlying sadness despite her morning cheerfulness. In your response, make sure to:
- Identify the two contrasting emotions Anne experiences.
- Explain how the beauty of the morning and nature temporarily affect her mood.
- Describe the painful reality that she cannot escape through her imagination.
💡 Writing Tips
- •
Look for the juxtaposition of positive and negative statements. Anne's cheerfulness comes from her inherent optimism and ability to find beauty, especially in the morning. Her sadness stems from the harsh reality of her situation and the temporary nature of her hopes. Connect her 'imagining' to her sadness – how does imagination both help and hurt her?
📝 Sample Answer
Anne's statement presents an apparent contradiction between her innate morning cheerfulness and her profound sadness. Her cheerfulness arises from her imaginative and optimistic nature, which allows her to find beauty and joy in the natural world, particularly in the fresh promise of a new morning (e.g., 'splendid thing that there are mornings?'). However, her underlying 'very sad' feeling stems from the painful reality that her stay at Green Gables is temporary. She admits to 'imagining that it was really me you wanted... and that I was to stay here for ever and ever.' This imagination provides comfort, but the 'worst of imagining things is that the time comes when you have to stop and that hurts.' Her sadness is a consequence of having to relinquish this cherished dream, making the beauty around her a source of bittersweet longing rather than pure joy, because she cannot permanently possess it.
Did You Know?
You can use the atoply app to practise this prompt and get instant feedback to help improve your writing skills.
Practice This Prompt