Harry's Secret Generosity
Harry was notorious for his competitive streak. Whether it was a board game, a spelling bee, or a playground race, Harry had to win. He’d often brag about his victories, sometimes at the expense of others. His teachers would often scold him for his overbearing manner, urging him to be more considerate. One winter evening, a notice went up for a charity bake sale to raise money for a struggling local animal shelter. Most children brought a few shop-bought biscuits. Harry, however, spent the entire previous afternoon in the kitchen, carefully baking dozens of delicious-looking cupcakes, each one topped with intricate icing designs. He didn’t tell anyone about it. The next day, at the sale, he put his box down on the table, still warm, and slipped away to join a football game, leaving the teacher to discover his contribution. His cupcakes were the first to sell out, raising the most money by far.
Task
Read the passage above. Write an analytical response answering the following question:
What do Harry's actions regarding the bake sale reveal about a hidden side of his character, contrasting with his usual behaviour?
💡 Writing Tips
- •
Identify Harry's typical, competitive behaviour. Then, analyze how his actions in the bake sale are different. Why do you think he acted so generously in this specific situation? What does his anonymity suggest about his true motivations? Focus on the contrast between his public persona and his private act.
📝 Sample Answer
Harry's usual character is defined by a 'competitive streak' and 'bragging about his victories,' often being 'overbearing.' This suggests a self-centred and attention-seeking individual. However, his actions for the charity bake sale reveal a hidden, genuinely generous, and selfless side to his character. Instead of buying something easy, he 'spent the entire previous afternoon in the kitchen, carefully baking dozens of delicious-looking cupcakes,' demonstrating significant effort and dedication for a cause. Crucially, he 'didn’t tell anyone about it' and 'slipped away' after placing his contribution. This anonymity stands in stark contrast to his usual need for recognition. His motivation was clearly not personal glory but rather a sincere desire to help the 'struggling local animal shelter,' showcasing a deep capacity for empathy and altruism that he usually keeps hidden beneath his competitive exterior.
Did You Know?
You can use the atoply app to practise this prompt and get instant feedback to help improve your writing skills.
Practice This Prompt