Old Man's Quiet Plea
Mr. Abernathy sat on the park bench, his threadbare coat pulled tightly around him despite the mild afternoon. His gaze was fixed on the scurrying squirrels, though his eyes seemed to see beyond them, to some distant, perhaps lost, memory. A half-eaten sandwich, wrapped in faded paper, lay beside him, untouched for what looked like hours. His hands, gnarled with age and etched with countless lines, trembled slightly as he slowly raised a cup of lukewarm tea to his lips. A lone pigeon strutted boldy near his worn shoes, pecking at an invisible crumb, yet Mr. Abernathy barely registered its presence. His shoulders slumped, weighted by an invisible burden. Occasionally, a deep sigh escaped his lips, barely audible above the distant city hum, a whisper of quiet sorrow. Passersby bustled past, their faces bright and purposeful, none sparing a glance for the old man whose very posture seemed to embody loneliness, a forgotten statue in the heart of a busy world.
Task
How does the author make the reader feel sympathy for Mr. Abernathy?
In your response, you should:
- Analyze the language and imagery used to describe Mr. Abernathy's physical appearance and behavior.
- Explore how the contrast between Mr. Abernathy and the surrounding environment or passersby heightens the sense of sympathy.
- Support your points with direct quotations from the text.
💡 Writing Tips
- •
Focus on the physical descriptions, his actions (or lack thereof), and how he interacts with his environment. What details suggest hardship, loneliness, or a lack of attention from others? Use specific textual evidence.
📝 Sample Answer
The author evokes profound sympathy for Mr. Abernathy through detailed descriptions of his appearance, his stillness, and his isolation. His 'threadbare coat' suggests poverty or hardship, immediately creating a sense of pity. His 'gaze was fixed on the scurrying squirrels, though his eyes seemed to see beyond them', indicating a detachment from the present and a mind preoccupied with internal struggles or sorrows, which invites empathy. The detail of the 'half-eaten sandwich... untouched for what looked like hours' implies a lack of appetite or energy, or perhaps that sustenance is not his primary concern, hinting at a deeper malaise. His trembling, 'gnarled hands' appeal to a sense of his physical fragility and age. The author emphasizes his disconnection from the world around him: a 'lone pigeon strutted boldy near his worn shoes... yet Mr. Abernathy barely registered its presence'. His 'slumped shoulders, weighted by an invisible burden', along with the 'deep sigh... a whisper of quiet sorrow', communicate a profound sense of sadness and hardship that touches the reader. Finally, the stark contrast between him and the 'passersby bustled past, their faces bright and purposeful, none sparing a glance', powerfully underscores his profound loneliness and makes him seem a 'forgotten statue in the heart of a busy world', prompting the reader to feel a deep sense of compassion for his solitude.
Did You Know?
You can use the atoply app to practise this prompt and get instant feedback to help improve your writing skills.
Practice This Prompt